Have you checked TV Fool for info on TV antenna requirements?
http://www.tvfool.com/index.php?opti...id=13&Itemid=1
Either antenna that you posted should be adequate for the 35 mile or so distance. The larger more expensive antenna has elements for low band TV (ch 2-6)... if you don't have a low band channel, it may not be necessary to spend the money for un-necessary aluminum, but with "repacking" in the future, perhaps you could end up with a low band channel someday.
Most "all band" TV antennas do not provide very high gain for FM, because strong FM signals could, in some cases, interfere with channel 6 reception. For FM dxing a dedicated FM only antenna on a rotator is usually considered to be a better choice. I use a (discontinued) APS-9 on a rotator to regularly listen to a Classical station about 100 miles away on my F1HD Sony.
More than you will likely need to know about FM antennas here:
http://ham-radio.com/k6sti/
Unfortunately the supply of of decent FM antennas has almost completely dried up, so you may be forced to just use an all band TV antenna.Even the little FM-6 has been discontinued.
http://www.solidsignal.com/pview.asp?p=fm6
hope this helps,
jr