Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums

Videokarma.org TV - Video - Vintage Television & Radio Forums (http://www.videokarma.org/index.php)
-   Early B&W and Projection TV (http://www.videokarma.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Floating ground ? (http://www.videokarma.org/showthread.php?t=261874)

radio nut 06-15-2014 09:15 PM

Floating ground ?
 
My wife and I just moved out of a crappy apartment and into a house(rental).
When talking with the landlord he told me that the house was built in 1925 and that currently the wiring while it has a circuit breaker installed it is only a two wire set-up.
One wire is hot and the other neutral, and does not have the third wire for ground.
Talking with a electronics tech. he said that my house could very well have a floating ground.
Well, how do I tell if it does have a floating ground and what would it affect?

maxhifi 06-15-2014 09:40 PM

I am not sure what he meant by that. The utility feed will certainly have the neutral and ground bonded together at both the transformer and the service entrance at
The house. Check voltage between hot and a water pipe or radiator pipe to check it, should be about 120 to ground. If you get any other value either the pipe
Isn't grounded or there's a problem with your electrical system.

dieseljeep 06-16-2014 07:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107036)
I am not sure what he meant by that. The utility feed will certainly have the neutral and ground bonded together at both the transformer and the service entrance at
The house. Check voltage between hot and a water pipe or radiator pipe to check it, should be about 120 to ground. If you get any other value either the pipe
Isn't grounded or there's a problem with your electrical system.

Get the electric utility to come and check it out.
The owner might be mistaken about the service entrance. I don't know of any homes that still have a two wire 120 volt service. They only were good for 30 amps, max.
The 1959 code required a minimum 120/240 volt, 100 amp, three wire service, for residential applications. It didn't make any difference, how many circuits were used. I've seen 100 amp services, that only had, two 15 amp 120 volt branch circuits. They owner did it to satisfy the insurance company.

earlyfilm 06-16-2014 08:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by radio nut (Post 3107035)
Talking with a electronics tech. he said that my house could very well have a floating ground.

He means that some receptacles might be reversed.

With that said, unless you were talking about commercial use, there were no grounded receptacles back then, so any polarized receptacles in the house are modern, and they may be wired wrong.

Back in the day, most electricians did not bother to mark which wire was hot and which was ground, as you could put in the plug either way.

To the best of my knowledge, if the house was built to code, and no new outlets were needed, you could leave in place any wiring that met code when the house was built. The laws governing this vary from community-to-community.

(Floating ground can also refer to 120 taken off a three phase circuit, where neither side of the two wires is grounded. This happened in some early buildings, that had phase heavy motors and someone goofed while adding a circuit. I've only seen this in older commercial buildings, not in private homes.)

James

dieseljeep 06-17-2014 09:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by earlyfilm (Post 3107126)
He means that some receptacles might be reversed.

With that said, unless you were talking about commercial use, there were no grounded receptacles back then, so any polarized receptacles in the house are modern, and they may be wired wrong.

Back in the day, most electricians did not bother to mark which wire was hot and which was ground, as you could put in the plug either way.

To the best of my knowledge, if the house was built to code, and no new outlets were needed, you could leave in place any wiring that met code when the house was built. The laws governing this vary from community-to-community.

(Floating ground can also refer to 120 taken off a three phase circuit, where neither side of the two wires is grounded. This happened in some early buildings, that had three wire heavy motors and someone goofed while adding a circuit. I've only seen this in older commercial buildings, not in private homes.)

James

Unless I've seen the wiring done in the home, it's hard to advise anyone.
I re-read the O/P and the owner was probably referring to the receptacles.
They were probably replaced with the newer grounding type. If the home was wired with the old style B/X cable, there might be, somewhat of a ground, but not a perfect one. If you meter the hot wire to the box, you'll get a reading.
If the home has knob and tube wiring or the old style romex without the ground wire and the receptacles, were replaced with grounding ones, it's a code violation.
Buy one of those simple, three light receptacle testers and it'll will indicate if the receptacle is wired properly.

radio nut 06-17-2014 11:44 AM

I will check the outlets with a tester this weekend. If not up to code...could the two wired outlets cause issues with my electronics?

Username1 06-17-2014 12:54 PM

Quote:

If the home has knob and tube wiring .................
I would worry more about this little bit of funky wiring, and the possibility of
FIRE and less about your electronics.....

And looking at my own house, and some of the stories on VK about house wiring
It does not matter what the code is, what matters is WTF they actually did....
And if the stuff made back then has any surprises yet to show themselves
because you may put a greater demand on them than what previous owners
may have......

.

oldtvsandtoy 06-17-2014 01:25 PM

1st you can not have a floating ground, you have a floating neutral. In your panel a ground and neutral can be one of the same, in your house they can not. In the old days your chassis was use as a ground. So if you plug your cord in wrong your chassis would be hot, and you could get zapped. This has happen and people did get killed. That is why we use the 3 wire system today. Now with that said here in Michigan a house must be brought up to code to rent it out. 3 wire systems are code in a home. You need to call city hall to see what code in in Ohio. Most likely it's a 3 wire system, they will make the landlord bring the house up to code. Or he will not be able to rent it out. You should check it out.

oldtvsandtoy 06-17-2014 01:37 PM

No you can have more then 30a on a two wire system. You just need to use bigger wire. A dryer can run on two wire 40a and a stove on two wire 60a
Quote:

Originally Posted by dieseljeep (Post 3107118)
Get the electric utility to come and check it out.
The owner might be mistaken about the service entrance. I don't know of any homes that still have a two wire 120 volt service. They only were good for 30 amps, max.
The 1959 code required a minimum 120/240 volt, 100 amp, three wire service, for residential applications. It didn't make any difference, how many circuits were used. I've seen 100 amp services, that only had, two 15 amp 120 volt branch circuits. They owner did it to satisfy the insurance company.


Kevin Kuehn 06-17-2014 02:03 PM

What scares me more than the old two wire system's, is the modern code approved twisted(wire nut) connections, and those crazy push in terminals on the back of duplex receptacles.

maxhifi 06-17-2014 02:58 PM

I think there is some confusion here. "two wire system" is being interpreted two ways, both of which are correct.

1. A "three wire service", is a 120/240V service. If you have a circuit breaker panel this is probably what you have. If you have an electric stove or dryer, this is definitely what you have. The "two wire service" which was 120V only, was a very simple service basically for lighting loads only, and it is very unlikely such a service would still be in existence. I haven't seen one since the 1980s and that was at a house which had been continuously occupied since the late 1930s... finding a two wire 120V service on a house these days is looking for a real antique.

2. "two wire receptacles" means receptacles without a third (grounding) prong. As previously mentioned, if someone at some time replaced the original two prong receptacles with three prong receptacles (as these are more commonly available), the third prong is connected to nothing and thus "floating".

I would imagine your friend is talking about scenario 2, so what to do about it?

1. With any "two prong" electronics this is an absolute non-issue

2. If you must, you can use a GFCI to connect three prong loads, it will detect any current to ground and perform the same job as a ground connection. The Canadian Electrical Code permits a GFCI to be used as a substitute for a ground connection in existing two wire installations - I am not sure if the NEC does or not, but it's a method to improve safety.

3. Add a ground connection to specific existing outlet. Get an appropriate length of #14 XLPE wire, and connect it from the third prong of the specific outlet being grounded back to a solid ground, such as the electrical panel enclosure, or a copper water pipe.

About wire nuts - my house was built in 1962 and all the "wire nuts" are just fine... wire nuts are fine anywhere except where there's vibration, if installed correctly. Push in terminals on receptacles though are just crap, I can't believe they ever got a UL/CSA approval

earlyfilm 06-17-2014 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107179)
3. Add a ground connection to specific existing outlet. Get an appropriate length of #14 XLPE wire, and connect it from the third prong of the specific outlet being grounded back to a solid ground, such as the electrical panel enclosure, or a copper water pipe.

Some locations require a grounding wire at the utility box and nowhere else. I got in a fight with the inspector in Memphis, because I grounded our washer and dryer to the copper cold water pipe instead of to the central ground. (Our washer and dryer were in an unheated, unfinished, concrete-floor utility room outside of the back of our house.) I did this because if something fails and the ground wire becomes hot and I wanted no possibility for a shock in this potentially wet area.

I then suggested to the inspector that I tie both together, and was told specifically that it was not permitted.

James

wa2ise 06-17-2014 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107179)
...The "two wire service" which was 120V only, was a very simple service basically for lighting loads only, and it is very unlikely such a service would still be in existence. I haven't seen one since the 1980s and that was at a house which had been continuously occupied since the late 1930s... finding a two wire 120V service on a house these days is looking for a real antique. ...

Push in terminals on receptacles though are just crap, I can't believe they ever got a UL/CSA approval

My grandma's house, in 1984, had that 2 wire service. POCO cones into the basement, thru a 30A screw in fuse, then the meter, then to a pair of 15A fuses, and the neutral also had fuses, we used 30A fuses there, so the hot side 15A fuses would be the ones to blow. If we wanted to, we could have easily grabbed unmetered power at that first 30A fuse. But we didn't.

As for the push in terminals, I've heard electricians call them "Push and pray".

maxhifi 06-17-2014 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wa2ise (Post 3107185)
My grandma's house, in 1984, had that 2 wire service. POCO cones into the basement, thru a 30A screw in fuse, then the meter, then to a pair of 15A fuses, and the neutral also had fuses, we used 30A fuses there, so the hot side 15A fuses would be the ones to blow. If we wanted to, we could have easily grabbed unmetered power at that first 30A fuse. But we didn't.

As for the push in terminals, I've heard electricians call them "Push and pray".

I am assuming 1894 :) - that's cool, my great grandparents house had that sort of a set up too, that's why they had a gas range and gas dryer.

maxhifi 06-17-2014 05:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by earlyfilm (Post 3107182)
Some locations require a grounding wire at the utility box and nowhere else. I got in a fight with the inspector in Memphis, because I grounded our washer and dryer to the copper cold water pipe instead of to the central ground. (Our washer and dryer were in an unheated, unfinished, concrete-floor utility room outside of the back of our house.) I did this because if something fails and the ground wire becomes hot and I wanted no possibility for a shock in this potentially wet area.

I then suggested to the inspector that I tie both together, and was told specifically that it was not permitted.

James

Yes, if you ground at more than one point you might create a ground loop, and get circulating currents. I said to ground to a pipe because realistically, it may be totally impractical to run a wire all the way back to the panel and there could be a water or radiator pipe staring you in the face. Of course I am assuming your water pipes are all metal and are grounded too, but given the age of the house it's probably a reasonable assumption.

Electrical code is designed in such a way as to be fool proof, but it is far from the only way to make something safe and reliable. Of course I am making the assumption that the pipe is a good ground, but it's not hard to verify if it is. Look at how wiring is done in Europe... much of it would NEVER pass inspection in north America but you don't hear scary statistics about electrical fires and electrocutions in Europe.

dieseljeep 06-17-2014 05:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kevin Kuehn (Post 3107174)
What scares me more than the old two wire system's, is the modern code approved twisted(wire nut) connections, and those crazy push in terminals on the back of duplex receptacles.

There's two types of wiring devices. Back wired and back stabbed. Back wired devices are the better quality devices. They have pressure terminals, that when using the back holes, you have to tighten the terminal screws to retain the connection.
The back stab devices, just have the holes to insert the wires. There's just a string type retainer to hold the lead. The screws are just there to connect the leads, if side wiring is desired. That is the best and preferred method. They're only listed for # 14 solid. The better back wired devices are listed for #12 or #14 solid or stranded.
Regarding wire nuts, they're only as good as the care used to install them. I've seen them burn up, from excessive load. That generally can be traced to improper installation.
Regarding K&T wiring: They claim that any K&T wiring, that remains unmolested, from the original installation is as safe as any other wiring system. The only negative is there's no ground available.

old_coot88 06-17-2014 08:08 PM

Some really scary stuff like house fires was recounted in the aluminum wiring fiasco.

Electronic M 06-17-2014 09:52 PM

I positively HATE back stabber outlets and switches! If they are not a problem then they are a problem waiting to happen. I've had those damn things kill power to other outlets down the line if you wiggled anything plugged into them the wrong way. When I replace any outlet or switch I always use the screw terminals...The extra time it takes is well worth it.

dieseljeep 06-17-2014 10:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Electronic M (Post 3107243)
I positively HATE back stabber outlets and switches! If they are not a problem then they are a problem waiting to happen. I've had those damn things kill power to other outlets down the line if you wiggled anything plugged into them the wrong way. When I replace any outlet or switch I always use the screw terminals...The extra time it takes is well worth it.

The new code requires that all receptacle connections be pigtailed, when the circuit feeds more receptacles down the line, just for that very reason.
The code can't dictate the method of termination, as long as the device is U/L listed for back or side wiring.
AFAIC, these devices should loose their U/L listing, as I'M sure, it is the cause of electrical fires. Usually receptacles used for portable electric heaters or window air conditioners. :yes:

wa2ise 06-18-2014 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107189)
I am assuming 1894 :) - that's cool, my great grandparents house had that sort of a set up too, ...

My grandma's house probably was built around 1894, but it still had the same wiring when my grandma checked out, in 1984. World's earliest BX cable, you look at it crosseyed, and the insulation turns to powder... The subsequent owner has upgraded the wiring, and installed air conditioning.

The house was a classic grandma's house, with a front porch, a back porch, full attic, and an added big kitchen in the back.

dieseljeep 06-18-2014 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wa2ise (Post 3107293)
My grandma's house probably was built around 1894, but it still had the same wiring when my grandma checked out, in 1984. World's earliest BX cable, you look at it crosseyed, and the insulation turns to powder... The subsequent owner has upgraded the wiring, and installed air conditioning.

The house was a classic grandma's house, with a front porch, a back porch, full attic, and an added big kitchen in the back.

I lived in a few houses like that, being the oldest section of town.
Many of them had additions, as well.
If the home has that early BX, it was wired for electricity, well after it was built. The real hi-class homes had gas piping in the walls. Slightly newer homes had K&T wiring, as well as gas lines.
The old family home was wired in the mid-1920's. Back then, the electric utility, subsidized the wiring installation. :yes:

maxhifi 06-18-2014 12:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dieseljeep (Post 3107248)
The new code requires that all receptacle connections be pigtailed, when the circuit feeds more receptacles down the line, just for that very reason.
The code can't dictate the method of termination, as long as the device is U/L listed for back or side wiring.
AFAIC, these devices should loose their U/L listing, as I'M sure, it is the cause of electrical fires. Usually receptacles used for portable electric heaters or window air conditioners. :yes:

Really? I hate how the solution to poor workmanship and poor product design is always more rules, that's a complete waste of effort and will require more deep boxes than usual.

Reece 06-18-2014 01:13 PM

I've seen electrical receptacles in old houses crumble into pieces due to overheating from using a 120V air conditioner.

maxhifi 06-18-2014 02:19 PM

I've seen "back stabbed" receptacles fail due to electric space heaters, but I think pigtails on every receptacle is kind of a heavy handed solution to an issue which has more to do with bad terminations. I could see making a pigtail for the neutral, but for both hot and neutral is serious overkill.

dieseljeep 06-18-2014 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107317)
I've seen "back stabbed" receptacles fail due to electric space heaters, but I think pigtails on every receptacle is kind of a heavy handed solution to an issue which has more to do with bad terminations. I could see making a pigtail for the neutral, but for both hot and neutral is serious overkill.

I think you're referring to MWBC, multi-wire branch circuits, where a shared neutral is used. The code also changed on that, as well. MWBC's, now require a double pole breaker.
Regarding the pig-tailing of the neutral only, I've seen the hot conductor also burn up. A termination, that is subjected to a continuous heavy load is subject to heating and becoming loose. If all that's being used in a termination is a tiny bent piece of brass, holding the connection, any heating will cause it to lose it's tension.

maxhifi 06-18-2014 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dieseljeep (Post 3107321)
I think you're referring to MWBC, multi-wire branch circuits, where a shared neutral is used. The code also changed on that, as well. MWBC's, now require a double pole breaker.
Regarding the pig-tailing of the neutral only, I've seen the hot conductor also burn up. A termination, that is subjected to a continuous heavy load is subject to heating and becoming loose. If all that's being used in a termination is a tiny bent piece of brass, holding the connection, any heating will cause it to lose it's tension.

Yes, that's just what I meant, for two or three pole multi wire branch circuits. I wonder if they need three pole breakers for three phase multi wire circuits now? This will be really annoying in some circumstances - say in an office if someone uses a plug in space heater and trips the three pole breaker to three or six desks, killing power to all the computers!

I don't support the use of "back stab" connections at all.. when I have wired houses I always use the screw terminals, even if it will take a little bit of extra time. I can't see how screw terminals are any better or worse than a wire nut and a pigtail though, provided it's a quality receptacle and they are torqued properly.

N2IXK 06-18-2014 05:16 PM

Backstabs should be banned, IMO. Has anyone else seen the REALLY scary PRC ones that don't even HAVE the screw terminals as an option?:eek:

The backwired pressure clamp ones are the way to go. Almost as fast to install as backstabs, and easier to disconnect without unlooping/bending the wire.

Rewired a house (Northern NJ) one time that had been converted from gas lighting to electricity (sometime in the 1920's). The sparkies reused the existing gas pipes as conduit for the lighting circuits! How they managed to pull wire through plumbing ells without shredding the insulation I have no idea, but this installation was in use up until around 2000. House went up for sale and buyers insurance Co. demanded a rewire.

Service equipment looked "fabricate on site", consisting of a slate panel with 6 open blade knife switches and bare wire fuses. A small hank of spare "fuse wire" was hanging neatly on a hook nearby. Looked like thin (~18 AWG) solid core solder. All enclosed for safety in an enclosure made from asbestos board! Insurance demanded that be professionally abated, as well.

dieseljeep 06-18-2014 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107326)
Yes, that's just what I meant, for two or three pole multi wire branch circuits. I wonder if they need three pole breakers for three phase multi wire circuits now? This will be really annoying in some circumstances - say in an office if someone uses a plug in space heater and trips the three pole breaker to three or six desks, killing power to all the computers!

I don't support the use of "back stab" connections at all.. when I have wired houses I always use the screw terminals, even if it will take a little bit of extra time. I can't see how screw terminals are any better or worse than a wire nut and a pigtail though, provided it's a quality receptacle and they are torqued properly.

Right at this point, the code doesn't address the MWBC ruling regarding, three phase 120/208 network, general use circuits.
Being a retired industrial-commercial electrician, I had to stay current, with the code changes. Might be a little rusty now, being retired for eight years.

wa2ise 06-19-2014 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maxhifi (Post 3107317)
I've seen "back stabbed" receptacles fail due to electric space heaters,...

Wonder if they have space heaters in the ISS Space Station? :D
I'm sure they don't have backstabbed outlets up there.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:49 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©Copyright 2012 VideoKarma.org, All rights reserved.