Ok, thanks for the recommendation.
I was watching a VHS tape, and even after rejuvenation, I'm seeing this now.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v3...psb6d2f32f.jpg
This looks FAR worse than it ever did. But here's the kicker, it's only doing it on this tape, not on cable TV, DTV, or DVD's. I tried the same scene from the DVD, and it did NO smearing whatsoever.
CRT still tests great, doesn't look like it's lost anything so far.
I hope this is just a bad tape.